Friday, March 23, 2018

Trading Log 5: fail!!

BTC #1 50 See explanation. Only worked because I took profits quickly.
 
YM #1 -60 Didn't protect profits again.  Was too cocky. EVEN THOUGH OBVIOUSLY IN CHOP ENVIRONMENT, WAS BETTING THIS TIME WAS DIFFERENT. Next time pay attention to "chop level"
YM #2 -40 Attempt to catch bottom. Complete fail based only on support levels and previous high volume. Chose wrong support level. Could have been a good short-term trade. I'm going to need to start just going short these moves or long as the situation requires. They seem to continue for a good while.

YM #3 -50 Attempt to catch bottom on same move. It did end up rocketing away. But notice how came back again and "double bottomed" a little lower...





Thursday, March 22, 2018

Trading Log 4: 3-22-18 Failure: -310

YM #1 -170
Accidentally sold a second contract short (a bit sleepy, was trying to set a buy stop...suggests I shouldn't be trading today). Market just generally made mincemeat out of the position. It happened very fast, so even with 1m charts I didn't get any bar edges with which to lower stops. Would have needed to look to left edge of chart, but didn't (esp because of 2nd contract). Note how even though market came back...it then went down quite a bit. So this was actually a selling opportunity on retrace to short-term bear flag.




BTC #1 -140
Did not use multiple time frames nor wait for volume to come in before putting on position. Result = buying in bad spot with upside objective. Completely wrong. Basically there was so much market weakness I should not have been expecting major rally anyway. Trade was entered because noticed that high volume spike. Basically, if price comes back on these high volume deals, it means it is not going to up and out. Volume just wasn't great enough. So cannot rely on it as backstop.



Trading log 3: 3-21-18 Multiple Trades, Success! $312.5

 Note: Trades via Think or Swim active futures trader functionality, demo account.

ES#1 -37.5
This was a short on contact with a major level. Forget how determined it, but noticed at blue symbol. However, did not aggressively protect downside, was expecting a move back to the lows shown. Instead, price formed this converging channel thing.

ES#2 +125

ES#3 +75


ES#4 +87.5

ES#5 -87.5
In this case we aggressively protected position but entry was simply not good enough. Entered on break of rectangle top, not enough downward price movement to justify trade, could have used Fibonacci to see this beforehand.

ES#6 +150

Total: $312.5
What really helped most of these trades be profitable: aggressive protection of position via stops. Since most of these trades were not major moves. Therefore it stands to reason I need to work on predicting major moves. Not so good at this. But still, "every trade starts as a scalp"

Tuesday, March 20, 2018

Trading log: Post 2, 3-19-18, Bad Entry, Scared Out

Unfortunately I was sleeping. My need for sleep and how often I stay up late is certainly a bane of my trading.

All the major indices broke out of potential reversal formations. I went short after verifying, but about 2/3rds down the breakout move past optimal entry...because I wasn't paying attention!!!) So not only is loss potentially greater, and profit immediately smaller, I don't have as much leverage as I'd have wanted either. It's a messed up situation.

But I decided to trade the "old ways" and not care so much about the immediate short-term entry--since I  had already missed it after all.

3-20-18:
All major indices are printing different continuation formations. /YM1! is printing a bear flag and is the most dramatic/obvious.

If prices break out to the upside of said flags, I think I'd be in trouble. Don't want to move stops there though, because I'm not sitting on a profit. Attempting to hold on longer apparently. Stops should apparently be ideally at 10.35, which would be a $334 loss in my account, and a 3x that in Ben's. If I hadn't been sleeping, this would probably be a slight profit.

So, obviously not sleeping when market is open is very important. But I have a great deal of trouble with that due to the way my body is. I just cannot NOT SLEEP like many people I know can. So, the solution is going to bed earlier. Or somehow making my willpower get me up (good luck). Apparently I need to be disciplined about my sleep. But this is just...you know...it's such a disadvantage. But then anybody working a regular job has to get up at a certain hour. The thing is, without sufficient sleep my brain isn't working well enough and this can be dangerous for trading I suspect.

Will keep updating this longer-term trade.

3-21-18 UPDATE: Manually out at significant loss. In at 10.55, out at 10.28 on 5000 shares in IB account. The reason for the manual out: futures were printing a rounding top-type formation pointing to a downward price move. A large upward price move invalidated this formation, which gave a clear bias to the upside. Short-term. The risks are that after FOMC prices will really tumble, but then theoretically one could always re-enter the trade. Of course, it is probably more likely that prices will rise after FOMC as market returns to rally mode, given how depressed prices have been last couple days. It seems as if this move was a throwback into the triangle rather than a downward break as I started to think. The DJI triangle did break downward though.



Result: restricted from real trading for the time being. Back to paper trade. This is a result of balance of trade shifting to loss from profit. Until balance shifts back to profit, it is time to trade on paper.

Will provide another update in the future.

Update 3-22-18:

Overnight action due to Trump slapping $50B tariffs on China.

Thursday, March 15, 2018

Trading log begin--Post 1, 3-15-18, fail

Preface: I have historically enjoyed excellent success with momentum and mean-reversion trades having fundamentals in their favor, as well (perhaps that is what gave me the confidence), locked-in positions have also been important--so I couldn't bail on short-term contrary moves. I have never been good at trading per se. Even worse than taking profit. I am endeavoring to remedy this, and improve my trading acumen. It is said that trade logs are extremely important to see what is holding one up. So, I begin.

Trade 1: missed (blue arrow). I also used a 3m chart, would probably not have noticed the formation on this 1m chart. I noticed price ceasing to decline and what looked to be a rounding bottom pattern. I did expect the rounding bottom pattern to continue for longer than it did, however, and thus wasn't exactly in a hurry to place a trade. Additionally, I noticed that while the pattern did occur after an extended decline, we were in post-market hours, where the odds of less-than-straightforward price action are significantly lower. Obsessed with getting a good price (such that I could have tight stops)--really, I would be trading 0.5 one ES contract during this learning phase, but do not have this option. Must trade a full lot. Or paper trade--which I have done rather successfully. As such I decided the time had come to use real funds in this endeavor. Obsessed with getting a good price I did the analysis paralysis then placed my orders at the then low, '45. By that time it was too late (I expected to have more time) Anyway, immediately after the burst of activity away from formation, I canceled orders and closed charts.

Trade 2: -$75 Coming back, to my surprise, price had exploded (still pre-market) and was edging down. I did not consider shorting for this reason, but price was retreating in an orderly fashion inside what I identified with excitement as a bull flag (on the 1 minute chart...yes) I then identified levels of S&R where I had high confidence price would reverse, expecting to get into said flag before breakout to upside. Price simply, although appearing to halt the decline halfway between my entry and stop, made one more downward thrust, with volume actually coming in this time. For this trade, I certainly should have waited for the thrust/volume on the downside then entered. However, with price over-extended we can see the trade wasn't a good one. In fact, not worthwhile taking. I honestly would have passed initially but I saw the 1m bull flag formation (a fantasy of my own making apparently) AND I HAD JUST MISSED A GOOD TRADE AND WAS 'HORNY'


Wednesday, March 7, 2018

Anatomy of leg 2 major decline



ES1! Respected TA on market open

Futures had dropped > 1.3% overnight due to the resignation of a US cabinet member and political tension due to Trump's talk of trade wars. Markets opened in this environment. The futures had regained most of this ground before market open, but the overnighttrading session was volatile. I didn't place a real trade for fear mkt would not respect the technical analysis. But it turns out, in fact, that in situations like these where things are really up in the air, technical analysis becomes the driver. Is this because investors are sitting on the sidelines? I suppose the way to tell would be to look at today's volume compared to the average. In fact, this may have some predictive ability.


Tuesday, March 6, 2018

Friday, March 2, 2018

The famous /ES 'double dip' strikes again

Fame in my mind at least. ES seems to bottom nicely for major bottoms, with 2 touches at approximately the same price level. For secondary intra-trend bottoms, however, it prefers to "double dip": first make a low with a candle wick and higher than previous olume on the 3min chart, then increment down a bit before reversing.

Thursday, March 1, 2018

BTC: Dead Cat Bounce? H&S?


BTC:USD was unable to break through its long-term downtrend trend line. More accurately, it was unable to break the overhead resistance shown in orange on its first and--arguably--second attempts. This sent price back beneath the long-term downtrend line.

There are 4 primarily scenarios as to what price will do next:
1. (My personal favorite) H&S reverse to breakout point.
2. Retest of orange overhead support
3. Continuation down before reversing at one of the fibonacci levels (most realistic).
4. Continuation below the "bottom" low into new bear territory with minor bounces along the way.

From my perspective it appears price is short-term reversing at a confluence of the .236 retrace and previous support. If price does reverse, it will likely come into contact with the purple trendline again. If it reverses from this level, it will be well on its way to forming a head & shoulders pattern which, if completed, implies a retest of the ~$8600 level, the original breakout point from the inverted head and shoulders bottom. The 50% retrace is also at this level. At which point it would be expected that price bounce again...likely it will continue up and not look back, but perhaps it will dead cat -> down. I feel this is a balanced but perhaps a fanciful scenario. By the time of publication it will be clear whether scenarios 1 and 2 are a possibility.

Alternatively, price may continue beyond the purple trend line and retest the overhead support, at which point price would be expected to fail briefly before potentially breaking through. This is the ultra-bull scenario.

Or, price may not reverse at the tentative H&S neckline and may instead continue downwards toward the .38 and .5 retrace levels. This would result in a healthy correction to the established price action by putting in a nice higher low and suggesting bullish continuation, especially if price stops at the 0.38 retrace. If it proceeds to the 0.5 retrace we would also have, in effect, a re-test of the inverse H&S neckline, which might confirm a bottom and therefore the end of the bear market. However, further price rise would not be expected to be as powerful. If it proceeds to the 0.68 retrace and rebounds, price will be severely weakened and a rapid recovery is not to be expected.

Finally, price may break all these levels, retest the lows, and proceed lower. This is the ultra-bear scenario, but wouldn't be out of the question given we are currently in bear market status by my estimation, also the 3K--implied by past corrections which have been in the mid 80% declines--and (potentially 1.3K--near the high of the previous run up) targets have not been achieved.

Trading tactics:

Trading scenario 3 on the short side is already out of the question. Short entry would have been the retest of the light blue channel. Take profit levels are the 0.38 and 0.5 Fibonacci levels. At these levels one might choose to go long depending on the price action, but immediately move stops to protect profit and prevent loss as price climbs, in case it proceeds to a further level. If one expects a 0.5 retrace, short on bounce off of 0.38 level, but this would have to be managed expertly.

Trading scenario 1 is relatively straightforward. Wait to short at the 11200 level on the shoulder. I would place stop around the 11400 level. Bear in mind that the right shoulder may not reach as high as the 11200 level, but I would not place a trade below the 11100 level. If price continues on toward overhead resistance, one would be stopped out.

Scenario 2 would then be in play. One might short around 11700 and wait for a decline (but once again, protect profit will stops). Price might break this level right away, make another run at it after a decline, or, after testing it, form a double top and proceed downward. A retest of this level would be a bullish event, however, since price would be above the long-term pink downtrend line. It would also have had the strength to evade forming a head and shoulders pattern at the pink line AND to have defeated continuing to the lower Fibonacci levels. Thus one should expect a break of this resistance to be in short order and therefore the best trade is likely to go long at the bottom (perhaps retest of pink) after the initial decline.

Scenario 4 requires the most caution. It will initially behave like scenario 3, however, will continue to break level after level. The most conservative play would be to short upon a conclusive break of the 0.618 retrace. The target would be the $6000k level initially. Price may double bottom here, so I would personally close short positions before this level and go long at this point if volume began to pick up but protect profits aggressively with a stop loss. This could be bitcoin's ultimate bottom. So be respectful and be sure to take profits. If a bounce from that level begins to roll over and fail, however, I would short again with targets at the much-anticipated 5K level, and then the 3K level. Beware though, in the extremely bearish case, price could go as low as the 1000s.

Note on trading instruments: I know of 3 ways to take advantage of this price action. All have their nuances and potential pitfalls. The least useful is the Greyscale Bitcoin Investment Trust (GBTC). This is because it is a long-only penny stock which tracks the price of bitcoin +70% or so typically. In addition, trading hours are limited to regular market hours, a dangerous way to play this at this time. The second are the various bitcoin futures. Be aware, however, that these cease trading at the end of the extended (verify for your broker) hours session on Friday. Thus one will be locked into a position over the weekend if one does not exit. Stop losses will not work and large losses could be incurred. The best is through a bitcoin exchanged called Bitmex. The disadvantage of this method is required to put up actual bitcoins as collateral. As far as I know, however, the exchange does not close, so one would be able to react to each turn of the market.

After reading this you might decide to stay out of the market altogether until price action becomes clearer. But if you choose to trade, good luck, and good skill!

---Addendum.

I am in a bind in that I still have physical bitcoin assets. It is of first priority to manage these properly. Given the complexity with regards to trading in the current environment, it will not be easy. Second priority is to use futures to profit on anticipated price direction.

Scenario 1 is straightforward. Sell the (formely) $2000 USD worth of bitcoin I purchased on Coinbase---sell on GDAX this time. Then also short at this 11200 level. As always, tighten stops if possible.

In case of scenario 2: stops will be tight so I will be stopped out of scenario 1 trade. Buy on retest of pink trendline and monitor carefully.

Scenario 3 is more difficult (and of course 4). When will price stop is the question? Magic seems to think it will stop at the .38 resistance level (a bigger inverted H&S pattern). So basically the futures strategy will be to buy each level when price seems to be bottoming, but aggressively move up stops. I will be paper trading this. It'll be difficult to know if it's best to sell the coinbase holdings, however. Honestly the best time to sell was when price was declining from the failed breakout attempt, but I did not recognize this as such at that time. That is why I became so sad when the trade went sour: I hadn't considered all the possibilities, and certainly wasn't using longer-term time frames...I was counting on the breakout. Over-leveraged. With poor risk management. And my accounts definitely paid the price as a result. This was a horrible oversight. Good news is I had enough discretion not to plow everything into what I considered nearly a sure thing. Stayed within the 5% for high probability trades, then moved stops up to make that 2%--even though they did not trigger since I used the wrong type, and catastrophic loss resulted, I still did not lose more than 5% of account in Ben's case, 3% in my case. So there is a victory to be celebrated here: proper trade sizing prevents calamity, read all about it! But still, the trade was a bad one, mostly because the analysis was not thurough and I decided to fomo entry AGAIN.


It looks like my funds may just be "stuck" in coinbase for the time being. I am running out of gas for my lifestyle (due to my investment of 1/3 of it!). May need to draw from my trading accounts. Will definitely need to start the business soon so I can draw from Ben's. 10K or so there I'd say he's owing. That'd be enough for awhile.

Problem is scenario 3 and 4 are just so...shall we say...disturbing. I don't want to lose. The other thing can do, of course, is hedge my .18 btc with...no wait, futures contracts are 1btc. overkill for sure. That's kindof good news though, because one short contract can make up for the physical decline I may experience.

So here's the gig. If price breaks below the supposed head n' shoulders formation, I will short 1 futures contract in my personal account with a TP target of that 9500 retrace. I will take profits out and funnel them to my bank account, since this is to offset the Coinbase investment. I will not trade Ben's account, will wait for better opportunities. Then on rebound, I may short again. We will have to see. On break of .38 level perhaps.

Plan in place. Now I just need to monitor the markets and look for that break. I will set alert on etrade



When a rally looks unreasonable given market context, even if you're in a "long term trade" it probably is. Look to take profits. 2nd picture little bump on left would have been a great spot. Don't fool yourself. A hefty profit in the hand is worth 5 in market mist.